Arsenal need a big comeback to go ahead, while Newcastle are keen to hold on to a 2-0 lead. Who will reach the final? The pressure could not be greater when Arsenal take on Newcastle United at St James’ Park for the second leg of their Carabao Cup Semi-Final. Having suffered a 2-0 first-leg defeat at the Emirates Stadium, the Gunners have a mountain to climb. Meanwhile, riding a hot streak of form, Newcastle will be keen to finish the job and secure their place in the final.
When & Where: Carabao Cup Semi-Final
Match: Newcastle United vs Arsenal
Competition: EFL Cup 2024/25
Date: 5 Feb 2025
Venue: St. James’s Park
Time: 20:00 UTC, 15:00 EST
Mikel Arteta’s side find themselves in a difficult position, needing a comeback to keep their silverware hopes alive. The Gunners are still reeling from their FA Cup exit at the hands of Manchester United, and another exit would be a bitter pill to swallow. Playing away ground, Arsenal will need their attacking firepower, with Martin Odegaard expected to lead the way. Bukayo Saka’s absence through injury is a blow, but the north London side cannot afford to make excuses – they need a statement performance.
In recent meetings, Newcastle have proven to be a thorn in Arsenal’s side. They have won three of their last six meetings with the Gunners, including a first-leg victory. They are in excellent form, having won eight of their last ten games in all competitions. The Magpies have pace, confidence, and a two-goal cushion, which makes them favorites to progress.

However, recent games have shown that Arsenal struggle at Newcastle, and Arteta’s side will know that the hostile James Park crowd can add to the pressure. If they can weather the storm early on, their counter-attacking approach could seal the tie.
Newcastle United vs Arsenal Prediction
Arsenal will throw everything at this game, but Newcastle has the advantage. The question is: can the Gunners produce one of their famous comebacks, or will Newcastle complete the job and continue their quest for silverware?
Prediction: Newcastle United 2-2 Arsenal




